SocialPilot vs Metricool and 8 more tools for scheduling and comment replies in 2026

Ryan | Founder of BetterSocials

November 17, 2026 · 9 min read

For a small business that wants scheduling and comment replies in one social media scheduler, BetterSocials comes first. It posts to six platforms and answers comments and DMs in your voice from one inbox, from $29 a month for four accounts. Metricool is the free start with an inbox, and SocialPilot pairs Instagram replies with its calendar.

Which tool schedules posts and answers comments for a small business?

SocialPilot and Metricool both let you schedule posts and reply to comments in the same tool. A social inbox is one screen that collects the comments and DMs from every account you connect.

Pick Metricool if you want a free plan with an inbox and you type your own replies. Its paid plans cost $20 a month, priced per brand, as of October 2026. Pick SocialPilot if you want Instagram comments and messages answered beside your posting calendar.

Pick BetterSocials if your comments and DMs bring in customers. It adds comment-to-DM, where a keyword in an Instagram or Facebook comment sends that person a DM with your link, and AI replies written in your voice.

How did we pick these 10 tools?

BetterSocials is our product, and we put it first. We checked each one against five things a small business needs:

  • It posts to the platforms a small business uses.
  • Its inbox holds comments, and ideally DMs, next to the calendar.
  • A keyword comment can send a DM with your link.
  • AI drafts replies that you approve before they go out.
  • The price holds up at the same account count, with the billing period stated.

BetterSocials: best for owners who sell through comments and DMs

BetterSocials is best for owners who sell through comments and DMs, and it's our own product. It posts and schedules to Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, YouTube, Threads and LinkedIn from one place. Every comment and DM from those accounts lands in one Inbox, with Needs reply and Replied views.

AI replies has two sections, Comments and DMs, and each has three settings: Off, Draft for me and Reply in my voice. Draft for me writes a reply in your voice the moment a comment or DM arrives, and nothing posts until you approve it. Reply in my voice answers everyday comments 1 to 5 minutes later and DMs in about a minute. When your AI rules don't cover a question, it waits for you in Needs reply.

A keyword in an Instagram or Facebook comment sends the person a DM with your link, with no flow builder. On TikTok, YouTube, Threads and LinkedIn Company Pages, the keyword posts a public reply with the link instead.

Creator is $29 a month for four accounts and one login. Pro is $49 a month for six accounts. Team is $99 a month for 12 accounts and unlimited teammates. Every plan has unlimited contacts and a 7-day free trial, card required.

BetterSocials has no free plan, and it doesn't connect X, email inboxes or WhatsApp. TikTok DMs are reply-only, and Instagram only lets a business reply to a DM within 24 hours of the person's last message. Start your free trial or see how it works.

SocialPilot: best for Instagram replies beside the calendar

SocialPilot is best for a business that wants Instagram comments and messages answered beside its posting calendar. SocialPilot's help center walks through replying to Instagram comments and messages in SocialPilot.

If you also want a keyword comment to send a DM with your link, BetterSocials does that on Instagram and Facebook. Its AI then drafts the rest of your comment and DM replies in your voice.

Metricool: best for a free start with an inbox

Metricool is best for a business that wants a free start with an inbox. Metricool's inbox comes with the free plan and reads YouTube comments there too, and LinkedIn joins the inbox on Starter. Its help center explains how to manage messages and comments from Metricool. Paid plans cost $20 a month, priced per brand.

Metricool is cheaper than BetterSocials, and the free plan is the reason to start there. In BetterSocials, a keyword in an Instagram or Facebook comment sends the person a DM with your link.

BetterSocials Creator costs $29 a month for four accounts. Over Metricool, that buys keyword comment-to-DM on Instagram and Facebook, and BetterSocials drafts replies to comments and DMs in your voice. We set the two side by side in the best Metricool alternative with an inbox and AI replies.

Agorapulse: best for teams that assign replies

Agorapulse is best for teams that hand replies to different people. Agorapulse puts one combined inbox on every tier, and its pricing page lists comment assignment, reply collision detection, Google reviews moderation and AI reply suggestions. Email is not in its channel list.

Agorapulse costs $79 per user a month on annual billing, as of October 2026, so a team of three pays for three seats. BetterSocials Team is $99 a month for 12 accounts and unlimited teammates. Pick Agorapulse when assignment and Google reviews matter more to you than keyword DMs.

Buffer: best for cheap scheduling with comment replies

Buffer is best for a business that mostly schedules posts and answers a few comments by hand. Buffer costs $5 a channel a month on annual billing, as of October 2026, and its inbox reads YouTube comments. The inbox covers comments only, so Instagram and Facebook DMs stay in the phone app.

Buffer is cheaper at four accounts: 4 x $5 = $20 a month on annual billing. BetterSocials Creator is $29 a month. The $9 difference buys the DM side of the inbox, AI replies and keyword comment-to-DM. We priced more of them in 8 Buffer alternatives that post and handle your replies, priced for 2026.

Later: best for Instagram and TikTok comment replies

Later is best for brands that live on Instagram and also answer TikTok comments. Later's Conversations inbox covers Instagram DMs and comments, Facebook DMs and comments and TikTok comments. It starts on Growth at $37.50 a month billed yearly, or $50 monthly, as of October 2026.

Later has no YouTube conversations and no LinkedIn conversations. BetterSocials puts YouTube comments, LinkedIn Company Page comments and TikTok DMs in the same inbox, from $29 a month for four accounts.

Vista Social: best for two-person teams that want DM automations

Vista Social is best for two-person teams that want DM automations. Vista Social pairs a social inbox with DM automations from Professional, which includes two users, at $99 a month or $80 billed yearly, as of October 2026. It offers a 14-day trial without a card.

BetterSocials also sends a DM from a keyword comment on Instagram and Facebook, and it adds AI replies in your voice. Creator and Pro are one login each, so a second person needs Team at $99 a month for 12 accounts.

Pallyy: best for a low-priced inbox with Google reviews

Pallyy is best for a business that wants a low-priced inbox with Google reviews in it. Pallyy's inbox starts on Pro at $25 a month, or $20 billed yearly, as of October 2026. It covers Instagram DMs and comments, Facebook messages and comments, LinkedIn comments, TikTok comments and Google reviews.

Pallyy has no YouTube in its inbox. Pick Pallyy if reviews matter as much to you as comments, and pick BetterSocials if YouTube comments and keyword DMs matter more.

Hootsuite: best for teams already paying per user

Hootsuite is best for teams that already budget per user. Hootsuite includes its inbox from Standard at $99 per user a month, billed annually, as of October 2026. A team of three pays for three seats, just under three hundred dollars a month.

BetterSocials puts YouTube comments in the same inbox as Instagram, Facebook and TikTok, from $29 a month for four accounts.

Sprout Social: best for larger teams with a per-seat budget

Sprout Social is best for larger teams with a per-seat budget. Sprout Social puts its inbox on Standard at $199 per seat a month, billed annually, as of October 2026.

A small business with one owner pays $199 a month for that one seat. BetterSocials Creator is $29 a month for four accounts and one login.

How do these tools compare on price and replies?

BetterSocials comes first because it's our product. Prices are per month, as of October 2026.

ToolBest forPriceStandout
BetterSocialsSellers in comments and DMs$29/mo, 4 accountsAI replies and keyword DMs
MetricoolA free start with an inboxFree, or $20/mo per brandYouTube comments on free plan
AgorapulseTeams that assign replies$79/user/mo, annualAssignment and Google reviews
BufferCheap scheduling, comments only$5/channel/mo, annualYouTube comments, no DMs
LaterInstagram and TikTok comment replies$37.50/mo yearly, $50 monthlyConversations inbox on Growth
Vista SocialTwo-person teams with DM automations$99/mo, $80 yearlyDM automations, two users
PallyyLow-priced inbox with reviews$25/mo, $20 yearlyGoogle reviews in the inbox
HootsuiteTeams paying per user$99/user/mo, annualInbox from Standard
Sprout SocialLarger per-seat teams$199/seat/mo, annualInbox on Standard

At four accounts on yearly billing, Buffer costs 4 x $5 = $20 a month. BetterSocials Creator costs $29 a month. Metricool starts free. For a team of three on annual billing, Agorapulse runs over two hundred dollars a month and Hootsuite just under three hundred. BetterSocials Team is $99 a month.

Frequently asked questions

Is SocialPilot or Metricool better for scheduling and comment replies?+

Metricool is the easier start, because its inbox comes with the free plan and reads YouTube comments. SocialPilot's help center covers replying to Instagram comments and messages in SocialPilot. Pick BetterSocials if you want a keyword comment on Instagram or Facebook to send a DM with your link.

What is the best tool for scheduling posts and replying to comments in one place?+

BetterSocials, if comments and DMs bring you customers. It schedules to Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, YouTube, Threads and LinkedIn, then answers comments and DMs in your voice from one inbox, from $29 a month for four accounts. Metricool suits a free start.

Does Metricool have a free plan with an inbox?+

Yes. Metricool's inbox comes with the free plan and reads YouTube comments there too. LinkedIn joins the inbox on Starter, and paid plans cost $20 a month per brand. If you want a keyword comment to send a DM with your link, BetterSocials does that on Instagram and Facebook.

Can a scheduler send a DM when someone comments a keyword?+

BetterSocials sends a DM with your link when someone comments a keyword on Instagram or Facebook, with no flow builder and unlimited contacts. Vista Social includes DM automations from Professional. On TikTok and YouTube no tool can turn a comment into a private DM, so the keyword posts a public reply with your link.

Which schedulers answer YouTube comments from the same inbox?+

BetterSocials, Metricool and Buffer all read YouTube comments in their inbox, and Metricool does it on the free plan. BetterSocials also drafts each YouTube reply in your voice. YouTube has no DM API for any tool, so on YouTube every tool works with comments and public replies.

How much does a scheduler with a comment and DM inbox cost?+

For four accounts, Buffer runs 4 x $5 = $20 a month on annual billing, with comments only. BetterSocials Creator is $29 a month for four accounts with comments, DMs and AI replies. Later's inbox starts at $37.50 a month billed yearly.

Can AI answer comments and DMs for me inside a scheduler?+

In BetterSocials, yes. Draft for me writes a reply in your voice to every new comment or DM and waits for your approval. Reply in my voice answers everyday comments 1 to 5 minutes later and DMs in about a minute. Anything your AI rules don't cover waits for you in Needs reply.

Try it on your own inbox

Connect up to 4 accounts and watch the AI draft replies in your voice. Free for 7 days.